Abstract
More often than not, women are subjected to various forms of oppression, ranging from controlling their cognitive abilities to gastronomical and lifestyle choices. This entrapment of women within the social constructs of patriarchy is provoked by their biological status. Gender bias and subjectivity are two recurrent themes that run parallelly through Anita Desai’s novel Fasting, Feasting. This paper aims to analyze the subjugation and conformation of women in Desai’s novel and their calamitous consequences, such as rejection of education, disastrous marriage, difficult pregnancy, body dissatisfaction, and even death. This multi-layered novel examines how basic feminine desires are subdued through refusal and deprivation, to ensure the persistence of patriarchal oppression. Also, this paper will critically deal with how these affectations cause existential predicaments among the female characters in Desai’s novel.
Keywords: Anita Desai, Fasting, Feasting, Gender.
***
“One is not born a woman, but becomes a woman.” (Beauvoir 273) The opening line of Simone de Beauvoir’s Book II of Second Sex has been considered the apotheosis of gender identity and construction. Since time immemorial, women have been treated as second-class citizens in comparison to their male counterparts. This treatment has reduced the role of women as producers – the necessary force to retain the cycle of kinship. The pre-ordained roles of men and women create the illusion of superiority among men. Patriarchy manipulates social constructs to retain its power by instilling fear in women. It is this fear that establishes an ordered society - a hegemonic discourse where the man assumes the role of the subject and the woman the subordinate. In this way, the subject exerts his rule by controlling, oppressing, and owning the subordinate. Similarly, the subordinate obeys and sacrifices herself to reinstate her identity, existence, and essence. Furthermore, Beauvoir also addresses the status of women as an “Other” in a hegemonic discourse to portray how her existence is established only in light of the Self, the man “Humanity is male, and man defines woman not in herself but as relative to him.” (Beauvoir 301) The binary of Self/Other naturalizes the oppression of women by blending coded dominant norms in everyday life. Meriel Colenutt takes up this idea to explain how passive femininity stands at the receiving end of patriarchal hegemonic discourse,
Furthermore, gender can be seen as a discursive means by which one's sexed nature is produced, making it prior to culture suggesting that our bodies are passive media on which cultural meanings are inscribed.
Anita Desai’s novel Fasting, Feasting (1999) examines cursorily the deplorable conditions of the female characters in the hands of their male counterparts and society at large. Uma represents the macrocosm of Indian women, who are manipulated to adhere to the set standards of patriarchal discourse. The minor characters, such as Mama, Aruna, Anamika, Mira Masi, Mrs. O’Henry, Mrs. Patton, and Melanie, contribute to the plot by depicting particular facets of patriarchal dominance. On the other hand, Arun’s character stands in contrast to Uma’s representation. Arun enjoys the male privilege of being the only son of the family and the pride and joy of MamaPapa. His birth leads to many sacrifices by the women of the family, and he is sent abroad to pursue higher education.
The title of Desai’s novel is an interesting one as it portrays the contrasting consumptive patterns of two different cultures, viz., Indian and American. “Fasting” alludes to the religious practice of keeping a fast, whereas “feasting” highlights the sumptuous spread of the American diet. The Indian diaspora has a large presence worldwide. Around 30 million Indians live outside India, according to the National Portal of India. Irrespective of their place of residence, Indians tend to unfailingly follow their native customs, as these practices are rooted in their subconscious. It is important to notice that Indians often enjoy delectable meals, but in a different diaspora, like America, their tastebuds are not satisfied due to the limited vegetarian options. So, the title, Fasting, Feasting, continually shifts its meaning as a result of gender dynamics and diasporic consciousness.
India is a land of peculiarities. The paradoxical sociocultural condition of India often leaves the audience bewildered. The Indian landmass is bestowed with one of the most fertile landscapes in the whole world, owing to numerous tributaries and distributaries of the major perennial rivers. However, surprisingly enough, the country has witnessed the most horrific disaster of the twentieth century – the Bengal famine of 1943. Nearly, 3 million people lost their lives due to starvation. Starvation, along with occasional droughts, has culturally influenced the food habits of the Indians. Women, being the epitome of sacrificial services, often shared or donated their food to the children or the male members of the family. This sacrifice has gradually assumed the role of gendered discrimination in food habits. The implicit rules often dictate that women consume foods in lesser quantities to leave out a sufficient quantity of meals for men.
This paper aims to discuss how sociocultural dictates affect women due to their gendered status by highlighting the stupendous influence of patriarchy in society. Also, I will take cognizance of the different situations in light of the systemic oppression of women in a capitalist patriarchal society from a Marxist’s point of view, Fucouldian power/knowledge discourse, existentialism, and the logic of antilove.
Part I of the novel opens with Papa summoning Uma to order the cook for sweets and fritters. Subsequently, she is asked to write a letter addressing her younger brother, Arun, who is currently pursuing higher studies in the USA. For most of the novel, Uma carries forward the instructions of MamaPapa which restricts her within the ambit of an oppressive household. However, here, Uma does not display her servile nature as time and again she transgresses the threshold of her oppressive household with the assistance of Mira Masi or Ramu Bhai. Papa is portrayed as the typical patriarchal head of the family, “with one burning ambition, to give his son the best available education.” (Desai 5) Nevertheless, his “sharp orders” (Desai 17) obliterate all chances for Uma to receive a convent education as she is now endowed with duties like taking care of his newborn brother, Arun. Furthermore, Papa almost pimps Uma into a deceitful marriage. Papa’s decisions gain stolid support from Mama, as they hardly have any separate existence. They are MamaPapa or PapaMama. According to T. Ravichandran, their namelessness defines their singularity, a prototype of over-domineering middle-class Indian parents, [MamaPapa]:
…remain nameless throughout the novel. Yet, this namelessness does not indicate their anonymity but signifies their universality. They are the prototypical parents found everywhere in the middle-class families of India, who discuss, plan, plot, control, and govern the activities of their children, be it marriage or going abroad for studies. And in their over-domineering concern, they tend to ignore the inadvertent possibility of entrapping their own offspring. Thus, they do not give contingency to the fact that perhaps their children too can have a life to call their own. (Ravichandran1)
There are certain instances in the novel where Mama shares “few anecdotes” and “they acquired great significance because of their rarity, their singularity” (Desai 5). Mama explains how, in her day, girls were restricted from eating tasty foods such as sweets, nuts, etc. Moreover, Mama is seen surreptitiously playing a game of rummy or consuming betel leaves in fear of Papa’s disapproval of the amusement. Mama also goes through a difficult pregnancy to bear the most anticipated “son” for Papa. The suffering mother considered terminating the pregnancy as it worsened her physical health, and she was almost overcome with shame for the taboo that a late pregnancy carried. She perfunctorily agreed to Papa’s whims but the birth of the son elevated Mama’s status in society, “Mama’s chin lifted a little into the air, she looked around her to make sure everyone saw and noticed. She might have been wearing a medal.” (Desai 31) The manipulation of women in a heterosexual patriarchal family is not only psychological but also physical. Here, ‘manipulation’ can be considered a euphemism to tone down the harshness associated with exploitation. Papa’s subtle dominance over Mama conditions her in such a way that she unconsciously begins to follow his dictates as they appear legitimate to her. She fails to comprehend how her body is treated as a commodity for reproduction in a capitalist patriarchal society. Luce Irigaray’s essay “Women in the Market” illustrates how women gradually lose their rights over their bodies as a consequence of patriarchal oppression and exploitation,
In other words, all the social regimes of "History" are based upon the exploitation of one "class" of producers, namely, women. Whose reproductive use value (reproductive of children and of the labour force) and whose constitution as exchange value underwrite the symbolic order as such, without any compensation in kind going to them for that "work”. (Irigaray 173)
Thus, with the birth of Arun, Mama fulfills her duty as a mother as well as a wife, at the expense of an agonizing pregnancy. The banal name of Aruna signifies the anticipation of the son “Arun”:
It turned out that when a second daughter had been born, the name Arun had already been chosen in anticipation of a son. It had had to be changed, in disappointment, to Aruna. (Desai 17)
However, Aruna proves to be the ideal daughter of MamaPapa by exhibiting typical feminine mannerisms, marrying at the right age, and bearing children. She stands in contrast to Uma’s ineptitude in abiding by the social constructs set for women, such as marriage and parturition. Aruna’s derisive attitude and tone of mockery towards Uma originate from her sense of satisfaction with being triumphant in society. Moreover, Aruna pities Uma’s failure to secure a husband, the same way Uma pities Aruna’s constant striving towards a perfect family life. Aruna’s endeavours evoke the Sartrean idea that “existence precedes essence.” (Sartre 568) It is as if Aruna is thrown into existence, and her continuous efforts and actions shape her identity, i.e., her essence. Here, her existence is mainly defined in terms of her gendered identity, which is further established through her selective feminine choices and actions.
Aruna’s blissful marriage with Arvind is a solemn and sombre reminder of Anamika’s disastrous marriage. Anamika serves as a foil to her brother, Ramu, and cousin, Uma. She is portrayed as a graceful, charming, and educated woman who wins a scholarship to Oxford University. However, her marriage cuts short her ambitious educational journey and her life as well. Anamika’s tragic ending displays patriarchy’s attempt to deny women the right to education by imposing feminine duties upon them.
Yet, Anamika lives in a patriarchal society that considers higher education to be the prerogative of males and marriage as the major preoccupation of females. The scholarship obtained is used only as a means to win her a husband who is considered an equal to the family’s prestige. (Ravichandran 4)
Therefore, the power struggle is no longer gender-oriented but gradually assumes the role of a class struggle revolving around knowledge and power. The capitalization of knowledge ensures the seamless execution of a hegemonic power discourse in a culture. The Foucauldian discourse of power/knowledge highlights how the production of knowledge is under the control of the dominant group, and relations of power “cannot themselves be established, consolidated nor implemented without the production, accumulation, circulation, and functioning of discourse which operates through and on the basis of this association” (Foucault, Power/Knowledge 93). The all-pervasive nature of patriarchal power has continually victimized women intellectually, emotionally, and physically. In Desai’s Where Shall We Go This Summer (1975), we witness how Sita’s father exploits the ignorant village women by deceiving them about his undertaking. He cloaks his evil intentions behind his pursuit of knowledge. Surprisingly, no one questions him because of his gender identity and social standing. However, the magical aura of Sita’s father ultimately dissipates when the truth reveals its bitterness to her. Women’s education/understanding tends to disrupt the circular exchange of knowledge among men. So, Anamika’s prospective career came to an abrupt halt through her marriage. Anamika’s role as a productive woman is measured by the contribution, she made to her in-law’s house by participating in household chores. However, her productiveness is reduced to zero when the beating from her mother-in-law leads to her miscarriage, subsequent infertility, and ultimately, her death.
Uma could neither experience joyful matrimony, like Aruna, nor the inexplicable suffering of Anamika. Her ruinous matches and a deceitful marriage shatter her dream of forsaking the oppressive and tyrannical entrapment of MamaPapa’s house. The only time she can have for herself is when MamaPapa are out in the evening. She goes through her treasured items, relishing the freedom that is so rare in her life. In her rapturous state, Uma once contemplated having a career of her own, leaving the oppressive precincts of MamaPapa’s house, and living a solitary yet fulfilling life,
A career. Leaving home. Living alone. These troubling, secret possibilities now entered Uma’s mind…They were like seeds dropped on the stony, arid land that Uma inhabited (Desai 131).
However, Uma’s tractable nature repeatedly confined her within the domestic domain. The selfish interests of MamaPapa curtailed her academic prospects and the possibility of a career in the local hospital. Thus, she tacitly agreed to be the constant help of the family. The Foucauldian concept of power hints at the circulation of power in a strategized way by the powerful to discipline the weak. This power relation permits one to influence the action of another. This relation ensures dominance, submission, and resistance. Uma was dominated in several ways in her family. Her subservient nature allowed almost every family member to exercise their authority over her. The domination mostly affected her sanity. Her illness was neglected, and her sister, Aruna, expressed disgust at her epileptic fits during the latter’s marriage. According to Chin-Yi
Uma’s painful convulsions are hardly ecstatic spiritual intensities or heights but a painful handicap which serves to alienate her further from her parents who deem the fits an embarrassment to the family which further impede her ability to get married. (3)
According to Panda the alienation of Uma from the rest of her family is the result of
not only male jingoism but also [condemn] female disinclination, submissiveness, and passivity for shaping women's existence in patriarchy, where the so-called Male-Gods act as immutable lawmakers and women assist them in the course intensify the matter. (42)
However, Mira Masi’s sporadic visits, along with Ramu Bhai’s sudden arrival, emancipated Uma from the snares of patriarchal orders. The shared connection evolved from their shared imperfections that outcasted them in society. Uma’s clumsiness, seizures, and unappealing demeanour have alienated her. In a similar vein, Mira Masi’s widowhood and Ramu Bhai’s club foot result in their treatment as outcasts in society. Mira Masi and Ramu Bhai treat Uma with laddoo, puri, chop, cutlet, et cetera. They do not consider Uma a “greedy child” (Desai 38) like her parents. Remarks like this affect Uma in such a way that she refuses to vocalize her cravings “Uma finds saliva gathering at the corners of her mouth at the smell of the spiced, roasted gram but decides to say nothing” (Desai 12). Several instances in the novel shed light on how women’s appetites are neglected and treated as an aberration from the stereotypical image of a woman. Mira Masi’s widowhood has imposed on her a vegetarian diet. On losing her husband, she loses her status in society. A similar situation arises in The Lowland (2013) by Jhumpa Lahiri when Gauri is denied the right to consume fish by her mother-in-law, Bjioli, after the death of the former’s husband. The miserable state of a widow is clearly portrayed in the localized term - “The ordinary term for a widow in India is “vidhwa” which originates from the Sanskrit word “vidh” which means “to be destitute.” (Verma) The end of a marital bond excludes a widow from society, and quite ironically, the destitute state of a widow is not self-imposed but rather one of the subterfuges of patriarchy,
It was also believed that once her husband died, the wife should pronounce all comforts of home. She should wear a plain white sari as a sign of lamentation. The appearance of widows at rituals, ceremonies and celebrations was considered unpropitious. Those coming from orthodox families, in some cases, even shove the woman’s head after the death of husband. This was particularly done to make the widow sexually unattractive, so that no man is attracted to her or she never gets married (Verma).
Since she is no longer a wife - the server, carer, and attendant to the man - the provider and protector, Mira Masi is denied the right to consume meat. This situation illustrates the oppression and control of patriarchy over a widow’s body. The willing act of self-abnegation by Mira Masi further reinstates her existence in the patriarchal paradigm. Her social status becomes her identity. Not only does she lose her right over her body but she is also denied a land of her own. She even travels from one relative’s place to another in search of a temporary shelter and also to serve as “mobile labour” (Atwal). Furthermore, with Mira Masi and Ramu Bhai, Uma trespasses the limits that MamaPapa set for her. However, the newfound euphoria is short-lived. MamaPapa’s interference after she almost drowns in the river, the long stay at the Ashram, and the brief dinner outing with Ramu Bhai abruptly halt her unsupervised life, and she is reintroduced to the yoke of oppression on “Papa’s orders.” (Desai 62) Later, in the novel we see how Papa rejects Dr. Dutt’s offer for Uma to work at the medical institute as he thinks “…of working women, of women who dared presume to step into the world he occupied” (Desai 143). The paternalistic norms of Papa perpetuate gender discrimination and inequity in responsibilities. The ideological traditional masculinity establishes a gender hierarchy that aims to “subordinate women and legitimize men’s privileged status in society” (Valsecchi et al. 147). In this gender hierarchy, the male assumes the role of an active thinker, while the female becomes a passive listener. Raewyn Connell’s idea of hegemonic masculinity is derived from the Gramscian concept of “hegemony” rooted in class dynamics. In a hegemony, a particular class assumes the dominant position, exercising its privilege over the weaker class. Here, the hegemonic masculinity of Papa guarantees domination over Uma’s decision-making powers to emphasize his identity and social standing in society. Uma’s job offer makes him feel threatened, as the traditional masculine stereotypes stand in opposition to women embodying leadership positions in society. The power play and class dynamics limit the power of women to restore male supremacy.
On the other hand, Papa ensured a good education for Arun by enrolling the latter in St. John’s School, arranging for private tutors to teach Arun at Papa’s office, and finally sending him abroad for higher studies. Although Arun defied Papa’s orders to consume meat, the latter ultimately acquiesced to the former’s choice as he was the privileged male child of the family. Moreover, in the USA, Arun navigated a sea of troubles due to his vegetarian diet. The affable Mrs. Patton became his voice in opting for the food of his choice. We notice a peculiarity in the Patton family as the women exhibit strange eating habits. Mrs Patton, being a vegetarian, is forced to eat meat, whereas Melanie’s diet consists mainly of candies. Just like Arun’s confinement in the Patton household, Mrs. Patton finds herself trapped within domestic obligations and negligence “What I cook, they don’t like. And they don’t like sitting at a table either – like you and I do” (Desai 198). On the other hand, Melanie finds herself trapped within her body. She finds it uncontrollable and imposes upon herself a severe diet to gratify the social beauty constructs and also to liberate herself from her disliked physical form. Unfortunately, she is diagnosed with bulimia and anorexia. Melanie’s dissatisfaction with her own body highlights the emotional and cognitive processes that drastically influence an individual to meet a certain appearance ideal. This obsession with a particular body type results in weight control behaviours achieved by eating disorders. Helene Cixous coined the term “the logic of antilove” (Cixous 878) in her essay “The Laugh of the Medusa” to critically analyze how patriarchy manipulates women to cause self-hatred towards their own bodies. This hatred towards their own shape and form makes them their own enemies, to keep them preoccupied with their individual concerns and shift their focus from the fundamental problems posited by patriarchal ideologies,
The logic of antilove taught women that they are supposed to live in denial of their bodies and their sexualities, to veil the grotesque with a monumental silence, and to feel degraded by their lack (Daniel).
The power structure is, thus, retained by disallowing women from identifying with the centre as a result of their lack. This lack leads to a sense of self-denial among the women. This self-denial of Melanie regarding her body and the subsequent dissatisfaction with it endangers her life.
For ages, the collective voices of women around the world have been silenced to retain the subjectivity of patriarchal authority. The treatment of women as objects of fulfillment by patriarchy has reduced their status. Desai’s Fasting, Feasting upholds a familiar picture of the condition of women in any Indian family. The familiar voices of the female characters allow the readers to analyze the situation through their vicarious experiences. The novel also takes into consideration the deplorable condition of Western women to develop a narrative that portrays a wider social aspect of the pitiable condition of women in a patriarchal setting. Therefore, the complexities of gender identities must be dismantled to create a more equitable and inclusive society where women’s existence will not be justified in terms of their product value.
Works Cited
Atwal, Jyoti. “Socio-Economic Structure of Widowhood in India: Past and Present.”
Current Research Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, https://journalofsocialsciences.org/vol6no1/socio-economic-structure-of-widowhood-in-india--past-and-present/.
Beauvoir, Simone de. The Second Sex. Vintage Books, 1973.
Chin-Yi, Dr. Chung. “Social critique in Anita Desai’s Fasting, Feasting.”
International Journal of The Frontiers of English Literature and The Patterns of ELT, vol. 2, no. 2, 2014, pp. 1-6. Academia Edu, ISSN: 2320 – 2505. https://www.academia.edu/1818257/Social_Critique_in_
Anita_Desais_Fasting_Feasting
Cixuos, Helene. “The Laugh of the Medusa.” Translated by Keith Cohen and Paula Cohen,
Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 875-893, The University of Chicago Press, 1976, doi: https://doi.org/10.1086%2F493306
Colenutt, Meriel. “One is not born, but becomes a woman.”
The Oxford Research Centre in the Humanities (TORCH), University of Oxford, 2021, https://www.torch.ox.ac.uk/article/one-is-not-born-but-becomes-a-woman
Conell, Raewynn. Gender and Power: Society, the Person, and Sexual Politics.
Stanford University Press, 1987. http://www.sup.org/books/title/?id=2532
Daniel, Emily. “Helene Cixuos and the Menstrual Bloggers.” Medusa’s Body, 2020.
https://medusasbody.substack.com/p/helene-cixous-and-menstrual-blogging
Desai, Anita. Fasting, Feasting. 1st ed., Vintage Books, 2000.
Desai, Anita. Where Shall We Go This Summer? Orient Paperbacks. 1982.
Foucault, Michel. Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings,
translated by Colin Gordon, Pantheon Books. 1980, pp. 93.
“India at a Glance.” National Portal of India, https://www.india.gov.in/content/indian-diaspora.
Irigaray, Luce. “Women on the Market.” This Sex Which is Not One,
translated by Catherine Porter and Carolyn Burke, Cornell University Press, 1985, pp. 170-191. https://www.cornellpress.cornell.edu/book/9780801415463/this-sex-which-is-not-one/
Lahiri, Jhumpa. The Lowland. Penguin Random House. 2014.
Panda, Etishree Sagarika. “Fasting, feasting: From a Feminist Perspective.”
Paripex: Indian Journal for Research, vol. 11, no. 6, pp. 41-44. World Wide Journals, ISSN No. 2250 – 1991, doi:10.36106/paripex. https://www.worldwidejournals.com/paripex/
recent_issues_pdf/2022/June/fasting-feasting-from-a-feminist-perspective_
June_2022_3685815454_3504397.pdf
Ravichandran, T. “Entrapments at Home and Abroad in Anita Desai’s Fasting, Feasting.”
The Indian Journal of English Studies, vol. XL 2002-2003, pp. 115-124. IIT Kanpur, https://home.iitk.ac.in/~trc/Anita%20Desai-ff.pdf
Sartre, Jean-Paul. Being and Nothingness: An Essay on Phenomenological Ontology.
Translated by H. Barnes, Washington Square Press, 1956.
Valsecchi, Giulia, et al. “Men’s Gender Norms and Gender-Hierarchy-Legitimizing
Ideologies: The Effect of Priming Traditional Masculinity Versus a Feminization of Men’s Norms.” Gender Issues, vol. 40, 2023, pp. 145-167. Springer, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12147-022-09308-8
Verma, Shivalika. “Widowhood in India.” ProBono India, https://www.probono- india.in/blog-detail.php?id=172.
Issue 116 (Jul-Aug 2024)